Sleep Science

Night Owl or Morning Lark? What Chronotype Is, What Shapes It, and How Fixed It Really Is

If you just took a quiz that said you’re a Night Owl, or if you’ve just realised that 7:00 am seems like a different planet, it’s worth considering what that means about you. The nighttime/morning person’s distinction is an example of how different internal clocks can run at different times. Of course, there will also be variations in both what time you go to bed and the amount of sunlight/lights you are exposed to, depending on how old you are and which type of job you are doing (if any).

Although the label of night owl and day person is not a permanent designation, you cannot simply reject the label as a result of your preference, the hours you sleep and the effectiveness of your daytime functioning as these are three separate matters. The information shared here has been sourced from published studies and does not represent a diagnosis or medical recommendation. The answer to the question of whether you are a night owl or a day person is not important because it does not tell you anything about how you feel on a particular day; rather, your answer should tell you what the way you feel during your morning hours is.

What Chronotype Is — and What It Is Not

Chronotype is your body’s time reference point to the 24-hour day and is different for each person. Some people are more “lark-like” (early risers) and each person will have a different chronotype as a result of their genes. According to the researchers who developed the Munich Chronotype Questionnaire, chronotype is the phase of entrainment for an individual; when an individual’s internal biological clock has become synchronized with the external light-dark cycle.

Circadian rhythm represents the circadian day of 24 hours. UCLA Health describes circadian rhythm as an internal biological process that regulates, among other things, sleep, digestion and hormone secretion. It refers to your subjectively experienced chronotype. While everyone has a circadian rhythm, your chronotype indicates where your circadian rhythm sits relative to other people’s. Roenneberg and colleagues explain that different genetic variations produce different circadian systems with regard to the parts that comprise them and, thus, people will entrain to the same light/dark cycle at different times (some earlier, some later) because of these genetic differences. This is where the common terms lark and owl originated.

The well-known three boxes of chronotype (morning, intermediate and evening) are simply abbreviated, shorthand terms. In the Munich questionnaire, the midpoints for free-day sleep are represented in a smooth continuous distribution. The authors contend that the groups as grayed in their graphs are arbitrary classifications. Additionally, findings from a genome-wide association study of chronotype provide similar evidence that, although chronotype is typically assessed on a continuous scale, people can be categorized into “larks,” “owls,” and “intermediates.”

Three things the label does not tell you

Chronotype is more than just when you go to bed at night. If you are working a night shift, have a newborn or have deadlines to meet for work, you are being controlled by events in your life, not by how your body is designed to function in a circadian rhythm. Because of the impact free days (days not working) can have on sleep, researchers in Munich designed the Munich Chrono-Type Questionnaire (MCQ) to measure chronotype based on free (non-work) days. Chronotype is shaped by social constructs and biological constraints for sleep.

Chronotype is not a measure of how much time you spend sleeping. The genome-wide study of the genetic variants associated with self-reported morningness and eveningness also shows that self-reporting of morningness is only weakly correlated with recorded activity data that show your wake-sleep cycle. The strength of the correlation is so weak that the leadership of the Munich research group has stated that chronotype and sleep need are unrelated genetic characteristics.

Chronotype is not a measure of someone’s character. On one Reddit thread on night owls, a night owl reported receiving lectures about being lazy from the morning people who “never saw you at your most productive”. This is only an opinion of one individual. However, the above genetic studies demonstrate that there is a biological difference between being late (good for the body) and a lack of discipline to go to bed early (bad for the body). How much “multiplicative” impact lateness has on our lives is a separate question.

Normal Night Owl or Something to Discuss With a Clinician?

People who stay up late have a habitual preference that is most often compatible with their current lifestyle, and this would be considered ‘normal.’ People who experience a cycle of sleep problems that include both falling asleep and then being unable to wake up when their lifestyle requires them to are likely to have a sleep disorder. This pattern of behaviour can be seen in people who work in a manner that permits them to choose when they sleep.

The International Classification of Sleep Disorders (ICSD-3-TR) published in 2023 by the American Academy of Sleep Medicine, has included circadian rhythm sleep-wake disorders as one of the six major groups of sleep disorders. DSWPD is considered one of this group and should be diagnosed according to the full diagnostic criteria provided in the manual and not according to what is provided here.

There is not a specific place on the spectrum of DSWPD that can be definitively called normal. Clinical measures of DSWPD have indicated that determining the prevalence of this condition is problematic. One reason for this is due to lack of consensus on a cut-off point at which the extreme form of an evening chronotype can be distinguished from the disorder. According to population studies using established criteria, approximately 1% of the adult population has DSWPD. According to the AASM’s patient information brochure, some people may mistake DSWPD with normal variability in sleep habits or even insomnia. To determine whether or not you have DSWPD, the best way is to consult with a sleep physician.

Clinicians examine more than just how late you sleep. The review also describes the history they ask about as having a long-term problem sleeping and waking at socially assigned times while still sleeping normally, when given the opportunity to sleep at your own time. Clinicians must also rule out and treat other sleep conditions, and consider the individual’s mental health. The review includes data from a clinic that evaluated the melatonin rhythms of 182 patients diagnosed with DSWPD (Delayed Sleep-Wake Phase Disorder). The data shows only 57% of the patients actually had a melatonin rhythm that was delayed relative to their preferred sleep time. Having a schedule that is late does not always equate to having a body clock that is late.

The table below shows how each situation causes different questions to arise, and is intended to help you organize your thought process, rather than to act as a screening tool.

Dimension Ordinary late preference Worth raising with a clinician
Central question When does sleep feel easiest? Is a persistent timing pattern getting in the way of needed sleep or daily life?
What you might notice Later hours feel natural, and life mostly allows them Repeated trouble falling asleep and getting up at needed times; reduced daytime alertness
What helps the conversation Your preference and your obligations A sleep diary of workdays and free days, plus how your days go
What it cannot decide Whether you have a disorder Whether any threshold “proves” a diagnosis

The right side column includes additional signs and symptoms recommended by the AASM lists, including struggling to stay awake past a particular time to get to work/school on time; decreased alertness levels during the daytime; and not being able to get back to sleep during the night if you wake up. The second column of the document recommends maintaining a sleep diary before seeing your HCP. If your sleep-related symptoms match the right column of the document and have occurred over a three-month time span, please speak with your HCP rather than self-treating for DSWPD. The questions in the mismatched scenario are designed to guide your discussion with your HCP about your experience and how it may relate to possible DSWPD.

What Determines Chronotype: Genetics, Age, and Light Exposure

Chronotype has a genetic basis; it’s also affected by age and light exposure. The Munich group concluded there are likely three reasons why individuals have varying chronotypes. A large genetic study now adds sex to the mix along with age and light, and no single factor can predict when a person goes to bed.

Genetics: a population estimate, not a personal split

The best twin estimate was from the Finnish study, which involved 2,836 pairs of identical twins and 5,917 pairs of same-sex fraternal adult twins who reported their morning-to-evening chronotype on a four-point scale. The heritability for the Finnish twin study was 49.7% (95% CI 46.4–52.8). The remaining heritability was attributed to factors in the siblings’ environments that weren’t shared by the siblings. Heritability only describes how much of the difference between the twins is due to their genetic difference; it doesn’t say what percentage of each person’s bedtime was inherited.

Estimates of heritability from different studies are reliant on the means by which those studies estimated heritability. For example, a genetic analysis of 697,828 individuals based on the UK Biobank and 23andMe participants of European ancestry has identified 351 specific locations in the human genome responsible for morningness. Using just the data from the UK Biobank, the same researchers estimated the heritability for morningness as 13.7%. This type of heritability estimate is different from the twin study heritability estimate, so the two are not contradictory, but provide an insight into how heritability can change depending on the study design used to estimate it.

Individual effects size is that grounding it is the most substantial number. Using data from activity monitors, researchers have calculated the activity levels of the 5% of individuals with the highest number of “morning” gene variants versus the 5% with the lowest. On average, the least active five hours of the early morning for the first group occur approximately 25 minutes earlier than for the second group. A rare variant of the PER3 gene previously identified as causing a genetic predisposition for early sleeping was associated with only an eight-minute increase in the average of the early morning five hours among this population of individuals. While genetic factors may influence the timing of sleep, no individual variant completely controls the timing for this population.

Age: later through the teens, earlier after

Chronotype shifts with age in a predictable arc. According to analyses of the Munich database, chronotype changes later from approximately age ten to the end of adolescence at approximately twenty. Following that, chronotype will change earlier for the remainder of an individual’s life. School start times often do not accommodate this late phase of age-related development. For this reason, the same authors reported that adolescent individuals experience the most significant amount of “social jetlag” because of the difference in sleep timing between school/work days and free days. The UCLA Health overview describes this same trend for general audiences.

Light: the main timing cue

Light is widely recognized to be the most critical external cue (zeitgeber) for regulating the human biological clock. The Munich review indicates that by spending large portions of their lives indoors and exposing themselves to artificial light, people have developed a biological clock that runs later than it otherwise would have and has generally increased the distance between the biological clock of early morning chronotypes and late chronotypes. The review cites studies showing that rural areas generally experience an earlier chronotype than urban areas and also provides evidence indicating that communities that do not have electricity have an earlier sleep start time than people living in urban areas.

Field experiments demonstrate the rate at which the internal clock adjusts to change. An experiment conducted by the University of Colorado Boulder demonstrated that an participant’s internal clock adjusted itself quicker to their body-clock and sleep-timing after a weekend camping study during the summer months spent camping in nature compared to a conventional weekend at home. The difference in time was approximately 69% of what they found after one week’s worth of camping experience. This indicates that the internal clock has a high level of responsiveness to these types of environmental conditions but does not necessarily serve as a method to reset one’s internal clock.

While the various studies largely cite the same results, they were conducted as separate studies measuring different parameters which makes for a challenging comparison.

Study and sample What was measured Main finding Limit to keep in mind
Finnish twin cohort; 8,753 adult twin pairs Self-rated morning/evening type, four categories Heritability 49.7% Population estimate from one cohort; self-report
UK Biobank and 23andMe; 697,828 adults Self-reported morningness; activity monitors in 85,760 351 genetic locations; about 25 minutes between genetic extremes European ancestry; associations, not a gene test
Weekend camping study Melatonin-based body-clock timing and sleep timing About 69% of a week-long shift after one weekend Short, specific natural-light conditions

When evaluated collectively, the combined findings of the twins and genetic data suggest that heredity across a wide range of populations is significant. Still, the intertwined connection of many smaller heritable factors demonstrates the impact of environmental exposure can shift the timing of an individual within a matter of just days.

How Chronotype Is Measured — and Why a Quiz Isn’t a Diagnosis

Most research regarding chronotype is based on validated questionnaires. The best physical marker of the evening’s shift to daytime is called dim-light melatonin onset (DLMO), which refers to the evening (or morning) rise of melatonin in dim light. This physiological marker needs to be measured with the usage of timed saliva samples. A score obtained from a questionnaire will indicate a tendency and cannot be used to diagnose a sleep disorder or indicate a specific period when users may benefit from exposure to bright light or taking melatonin.

The Morningness-Eveningness Questionnaire (MEQ) consists of 19 questions related to your preferences for when you sleep, work, exercise, or study, as well as how alert you are in the morning and how tired you feel in the evening. The score range is from 16 (indicative of a preference towards evening) to 86. Researchers classify the MEQ as a measure of diurnal preference.

The Munich ChronoType Questionnaire (MCTQ) focuses on actual behaviour rather than preference. The core module consists of 17 questions. These questions ask about the time at which you go to bed, how long it takes you to drift off to sleep, the time you wake, and the time you rise to get out of bed both on workdays and free days. Your chronotype is set at the half-time from the previous day’s sleep during free days, then adjusted by the extra time you take to catch up on your work-week sleep deficit. Researchers refer to this set of data as MSFsc. There are also versions for those working shifts and a short version containing six questions.

Feature MEQ MCTQ
What it asks Preferred times for sleep and activities Actual sleep times on workdays and free days
Main output Score from 16 to 86 Free-day sleep midpoint, corrected for sleep debt (MSFsc)
Strength Captures how you feel across the day Gives a clock time and lets social jetlag be calculated
Main limitation Preference may not match the schedule you can keep Needs a regular work schedule and no alarm on free days

The MEQ information is compiled from the Kantermann research comparison and the MCTQ is compiled based on the Munich research review and the reliance on a structured work schedule.

Why two questionnaires can disagree about the same person

Both questionnaires were tested against DLMO over the same time frame; both demonstrated similar correlations (~70) with respect to the melatonin marker (MEQ 0.70; MSFsc 0.68). Together with age, they accounted for 60% of the variance in melatonin onset. However, melatonin onsets were found to differ by four hours for any one individual, so the authors of the study state that neither questionnaire should be used alone to determine the best time for light or melatonin treatments, as mis-timed treatments could worsen the problem of misalignment with one’s circadian rhythm(s).

This same patient group demonstrates where the MCTQ has a blind spot; thirteen participants did not complete the MCTQ because they used alarms on free days, yet 70% of them awoke at or after 09:00 a.m. The authors suggest that this supports the notion that obtaining a valid MSFsc result may be more difficult for individuals with later circadian types. Additionally, twenty-four of the sixty participants were diagnosed with delayed sleep phase disorder (a disorder classified as having an extreme chronotype), which makes using the MCTQ alone to analyze groups without extreme chronotypes inaccurate.

The more profound difference between the questionnaires’ findings stems from the fact that one questionnaire asks about the participant’s preferences, while the other questionnaire asks about the participant’s behavior. The authors of the Munich study introduce an additional element by commenting that individuals with extreme chronotypes in a highly regulated society may prefer a more moderate direction, thereby artificially inflating the difference between preference and actual behavior.

What an online quiz or wearable label can and cannot tell you

A chronotype test taken online could have been conducted using any of these tools, or not. In the same Reddit thread, one Reddit user mentioned that they took a health class survey that consisted of 30 questions and was graded from +30 to -30, where they scored a -28. That scale is not the same as the MEQ’s scale that ranges from 16 to 86; therefore, it does not appear to be the same type of the instrument, nor is there any information available regarding whether or not it was ever validated.

Wearables have the same problem; as indicated in the AASM’s position statement on consumer sleep technology, wearables are unvalidated and unsubmitted for clearance to the FDA, and cannot be used for the diagnosis or treatment of any sleep disorders. However, data collected by these devices could be useful in discussions with a clinician that is doing a complete assessment. A DSWPD review does refer to research that shows wrist temperature may correlate reasonably well with melatonin release timing, but concludes that more study is needed before it is an accepted means of measuring melatonin release.

If you are simply looking to identify whether or not you consider yourself to be a night owl, the MCTQ’s method will give you a basic indication, with no score. The MCTQ method uses the time of day that you wake and sleep, and allows you to make a comparison between your sleep patterns on days that you do not have any schedule related to alarms and obligations, and your sleep patterns on days that you work.

Can You Change Your Chronotype? What the Evidence Actually Shows

Your chronotype can change from time to time, but this is mostly due to changes in your home or work environment. Your chronotype clocks are also affected by more daylight and getting older. Thus, even though there is no evidence that a chronotype will remain in its early phase once the environment or age has changed it back to the original chronotype phase, there is still research from the Munich review that illustrates how chronotype returns to late from early when you stop changing the environment where you sleep.

The authors of the Munich review conclude that there is a benefit to viewing chronotype as a continuum rather than as something that will never shift. The authors state, “Chronotype in a real-life context may be more of a continuum than an absolute characteristic.” Furthermore, they also cite the results of a study where late types slept earlier by two hours after following prescribed light and dark cycles for three weeks. These same authors also state that following the prescribed light cycles was shown not to last past the end of the study due to the genetic origins of chronotype.

As the authors have pointed out, the body has the ability to adapt more rapidly than people typically expect and, therefore, that chronotype can change based on work and weekend hours over the course of a week. Thus, the authors argue that other rhythms, such as those associated with melatonin and cortisol production, will shift in sync with the chronotype as evidenced by the study’s data, on average, after only two days of sleep timing being altered by 45 minutes.

The Questionnaires did not follow the same timeframe as those Physical Changes. In another study on morning light treatment, a group of 31 adults completed the two sets of questionnaires both before and after participating in 13 to 28 days of Morning Light (ML). Again, in a subgroup of 16, the Onset of Melatonin had shifted on average to 47 minutes earlier over the period of this Morning Light treatment study. During this time period, MEQ only moved up by an average of 1.8 points with a MFSsc shift of only 8.7 minutes, both of which were not statistically significant. However, the changes observed in both questionnaires did correlate with the Melatonin shift. This study did not contain a Control Group which makes it impossible to segregate the Lighting Treatment from other variables that could influence these results.

It helps to separate three things:

  1. The predisposition you were born with.
  1. The timing your clock shows under your current conditions.
  • Whether a change outlasts those conditions.

The previous paragraphs serve as an alternative method of interpreting the data and should not be considered as a Clinical Definition of a social Shift. However, the pre-existing Evidence supports a shift in the Second Social Identity through Environmental Change (light) and Age. Although there may not be supporting evidence to support a change in the First Social Identity, the finding of the Relapse does not support the evidence presented in the Third.

The Social Shift “Readiness” is supported by a poster on the Reddit discussion who details their individual experience where they had spent years working the Second Shift and, having switched to a more traditional 8 am to 5 pm schedule, took a year to fully complete their transition and still felt that they operated at a capacity that was only half of where they once could be at their peak. Although this was only one individual’s experience, there appears to be enough commonality regarding the time it took to Transition versus the change in a person’s personality during the Transition to support this as a valid representation of the process.

So, can someone who identifies as a Night Owl become a Morning Person? Yes, that individual can make significant changes in their evening and morning routines depending on the Influence of his/her New Work Schedule versus the Individual Liability created by the Alteration of His/Her Circadian Rhythm. How much Benefit an Individual derives from making that Change will depend on how much Money they generate with the Change and how much Stress their current individual Perceived Mismatch creates for them.

What the Health-Risk Studies Actually Measure

The majority of the research regarding the potential health risks of being a “night owl” (i.e., someone who prefers staying up late) has only measured associations between a person’s self-reported bedtime or sleep schedule and their future health outcomes. There has been no research that shows being a “night owl” is a factor in developing a disease. Newer research has suggested that what might matter more than a person’s preferred bedtime is [actual late sleep timing] and how difficult it is for them to wake up.

The patient-education pages of many hospitals include the same association information. For example, according to UCLA Health’s patient-education page, people who identify as evening types have a higher rate of anxiety, depression, obesity, and type 2 diabetes. The page also points out that anyone who does not have adequate amounts of good quality sleep will increase their chances of developing a chronic illness. A recent genome-wide association study has highlighted the difficulty of interpreting the associations between chronic illness and chronotype. First, chronic illness may result in changes in sleep patterns or limit employment options (reverse causation). Second, shared risk factors can affect both chronotype and illness (confounding).

The mismatch explanation, and where it falls short

The Munich researchers are among the first to provide an influential explanation for the association between chronotype and chronic illness, claiming that the cause of the association is due to the conflict between society’s demand on time and a person’s chronotype rather than a person being an evening type. The Munich authors write that there is still little longitudinal data or pathway analysis to confirm their hypotheses and have developed a measure of “social jetlag” (a measure of the conflict), which is greater for evening types, and is also related to sleep deprivation, making it difficult to separate the effects of the timing of sleep and sleep loss.

There is substantial evidence supporting this explanation; however, it does not encompass the entire set of circumstances. The UK Biobank analysis of 73,888 adults compared questionnaire chronotype with sleep timing measured by accelerometer over seven days. Morning chronotype adults who slept late had higher risks of mental health disorders than morning chronotype adults who slept early. Evening chronotype adults who slept early had a lower risk of depression than evening chronotype adults who slept late. If mismatch alone were the problem, that second result would point the other way.

Additionally, a Stanford University review by the same lead authors concluded that the timing of actual sleep was more likely to predict mental health outcomes than chronotype preference. However, they also acknowledge that the biological and social mechanisms associated with sleep timing are much less understood than other factors, and cannot necessarily all be explained by the shorter sleep times associated with evening chronotype versus morning chronotype adults, respectively.

Difficulty waking as a clue

A genetic and epidemiological research study reported as a preprint evaluated data collected from 496,820 UK Biobank participants. The study reported that individuals with evening chronotype had higher rates of major depressive disorder, schizoaffective disorder, generalised anxiety disorder, and bipolar disorder than those with morning chronotype. However, this increased risk did depend on whether individuals with evening chronotype experienced sleep inertia (i.e. “the foggy feeling” that occurs after transitioning from sleep to wakefulness). Individuals with evening chronotype who did not have sleep inertia had no greater risk for these disorders than those with morning chronotype. In another study, a Finnish twin cohort study of 23,854 individuals demonstrated the same correlation between evening chronotype and suicide versus the depressive state.

The genetic data are ambiguous. Genetic data in a genome-wide study used a Mendelian randomization approach to control for confounding relationships between genetic variants and traits. This indicates that being a morning person may create a direct (causal) effect on better mental health outcome. According to genetic findings reported in the preprint, the effect of chronotype on mental health occurs through shared genetic pathways with having difficulty waking (which itself is strongly associated with mental illness, independent of chronotype).

A Reddit user in the Reddit thread commented that “articles on health risk never take into account that the night owl may have to adjust their sleep schedule.” Studies today have started separating sleep preference (when one prefers to sleep) from sleep behaviour (when they actually sleep). Thus the current studies indicate that it does indeed matter what time of day you sleep, however they do not rule out the possibility that the normal sleep behaviour of one having shifted to later timing may be the reason for that person’s current health problems; thus none of these findings indicate how healthy a person is.

What You Can Do About a Chronotype Mismatch

To address chronological mismatches in waking and sleeping patterns, one must first understand their differences. Start by writing out all the ways in which the two types of sleep differ, including what obligations you have during your weekdays as opposed to your weekends, and how those obligations have affected the way you wake on those days. From this point, one can choose either to adjust one’s own schedule (wherever possible) or to consult a doctor if the disorder continues to create problems.

At least one case study was conducted on schedule modifications in the workplace. A manufacturing facility implemented a chronotype-adjusted shift schedule, allowing workers who had extreme chronotypes to avoid working the hardest shifts. Workers who were late-rising no longer began their shifts in the early morning, and workers who were early-rising no longer began their shifts in the late evening. As a result, participants reported a reduction in social jetlag (approximately 1 hour), longer, improved (higher quality) sleep, and increased self-reported wellbeing on workdays and unaltered levels of stress. While health-related long-term effects of the intervention need further examination, researchers noted the findings.

Light and routine recommendations provided by patient-education organizations are generally applicable; however, they do not address the unique individual circumstances of each person. For example, UCLA Health recommends for night owls who need to wake up early, to obtain more morning sunlight; to limit evening exposure to artificial lighting; and to maintain a consistent going-to-bed time. The Cleveland Clinic website recommends exposure to bright light in the morning, exposure to dim light in the evening, and incrementally pushing the time of going to bed back. They also advise consulting with a medical professional regarding melatonin dosage. The questionnaire research above indicated caution that timing melatonin and/or light based solely on the results of a questionnaire has the potential for improper timing. Therefore, when a person requires timed treatment, it should be done with the help of a physician.

A factor list for describing your pattern

Overall, these elements provide individuals with information to accurately describe the situations surrounding their chronotype misalignments; however, assessing one’s situation cannot be accomplished through the assignment of points, totals or cutoffs.

  • Free-day timing. When you fall asleep and wake on days with no alarm and no obligations, ideally over several weeks. This mirrors what the MCTQ uses.
  • Workday timing. The same times on workdays, and how big the gap is compared with free days. That gap is what researchers call social jetlag.
  • Required hours. When work, school or caregiving actually needs you awake, and how flexible those hours are.
  • Sleep opportunity. Whether the time between when you can realistically fall asleep and when you must wake leaves room for enough sleep.
  • Waking difficulty. How hard the first stretch after waking is on workdays compared with free days. Difficulty waking was the factor that carried the psychiatric link in the UK Biobank preprint.
  • Daytime functioning. Repeated effects on alertness, mood or performance, and when in the day they show up.
  • Persistence. Whether the pattern holds when your obligations change, such as on holidays or after a schedule change.
  • Other explanations. Another sleep problem, a medical condition, medications, mental health changes or substance use. The AASM lists these as other possible causes to check.

How to read the list

None of the possible answers in this assessment prove you to be “normal” or “disordered.” It does serve, however, as a way to identify potential patterns, and you should interpret the potential results based on the sample you select below. For example, if your schedule has a significant gap between your workdays and days off, but you tend to sleep well on your days off, you are likely to have the schedule conflict described by the Munich group. This suggests that you may have multiple scheduling options available to you. However, if the sleep-onset and sleep-inability issues persist after you have reduced your obligations, there is a chance those same issues could affect your performance at work during the day, and perhaps also apply to some of the other potential explanations mentioned in the assessment. Those are the types of patterns that would be pertinent to the DSWPD review process and, therefore, warrant making an appointment with a clinician.

Questions to take to a clinician

  • What information about my workdays, free days and daytime functioning would help you evaluate this pattern?
  1. Could another sleep problem, a medical condition or a medication explain the difficulty?
  1. Would a sleep diary, actigraphy or any other test be useful in my case?
  1. Are light-based or melatonin-based approaches appropriate for me, given my health history?
  • What are the likely benefits and risks of any timing-related treatment you’d suggest, and what happens if I stop it?

How to Read Chronotype Claims

To judge a chronotype claim, check five things:

  • what was measured
  • who was studied
  • what kind of number is reported
  • whether the study changed anything or only observed
  • whether a quiz or device label is being treated as a diagnosis

Those validations help us delineate an appropriate fact from an exaggerated article.

This is where things get interesting. I came across a Reddit post with more than 30,000 upvotes that stated approximately 30% of the population falls under the night owl category or are genetically programmed to be at peak performance at later hours. In the post, it mentioned that UCLA Health’s page rated its percentage of the population to be 30% as the “wolf” —one of the four categories referenced from a clinical psychologist— but, ultimately, UCLA has not cited any research to support these percentages. Furthermore, the genetic predisposition was discussed separately from that statistic in the publication. The post took both of these topics and created a headline with both of them combined.

Use these checks on the next claim you see:

  • Definition. Did the researchers measure preference (like the MEQ), habitual workday and free-day timing (like the MCTQ), a physical marker like melatonin onset, or a device’s category? As the Kantermann comparison shows, these overlap but aren’t interchangeable.
  1. Population. Who was studied, and does the finding reasonably carry over to you? A camping study under specific natural-light conditions tells you something different from a national cohort.
  1. Magnitude. Is the number a group average, a population heritability estimate, an association or an individual prediction? The 49.7% twin estimate describes variation across a population, not your own genes.
  1. Causation. Did investigators change something and measure the result, like the factory schedule study? Or did they observe people who already differed? Observational links can reflect confounding or reverse causality.
  • Clinical boundary. Is a questionnaire score or wearable label being presented as a diagnosis? The AASM says consumer devices can’t be used to diagnose or treat sleep disorders.

The type of source is essential as well. News releases and educational pages from universities provide secondhand accounts of research. They can be used to assist in finding primary sources, but only the peer-reviewed publication supports the conclusions discussed in the headline, and not all conclusions that have been made up of everything in the article.

The Bottom Line

Chronotype identifies an actual, partially inherited differential of when your biological clock operates, and how age and light continue to warp your established chronotype. Therefore, chronotype is neither a limitation of your free will nor simply the result of your own behavior. To effectively attempt to modify your chronotype, utilize the chronotype factor chart to distinguish your actual preferred hours from those imposed upon you due to the demands of your lifestyle. If the time frame of your chronotype is consistently causing problems with your daily functioning, only a qualified clinician can determine whether your current schedule corresponds to the natural sleeping patterns of your chronotype (schedule mismatch) or indicates a medical, sleep-timing disorder (e.g., a delayed sleep-phase disorder). Neither an online quiz nor an internet-based classification system can determine this.

Frequently Asked Questions

If being a night owl is about half heritable, is my bedtime half genetic?

The 49.7% estimate shows how much of the variance in the Finnish twin population can be attributed to genetic differences, but does not separate the genetic and environmental influences on any one person’s timing. Different methodologies also yield different estimates.

Why might a preference questionnaire and my free-day sleep timing disagree?

The MEQ asks about your preferred sleep pattern while the MCTQ records your current sleep pattern, which you actually do. Due to sleep debt, alarm clocks being set on free days, and irregular sleep schedules, results from the two questionnaires may not line up. Discrepancy between the two questionnaires does not indicate that one or both are unreliable.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Back to top button