
Pick a pillow by how high it holds your head, not by its label. When you lie on your side, that height has to fill the space your shoulder leaves between your head and the mattress. Banner Health explains that loft and firmness together set a pillow’s height once weight is on it. A 2021 review of pillow-height research notes that foam and buckwheat deform under load, so a pillow’s stated height can’t be taken as the height you actually sleep at.
No study has settled on a correct number. The same review found “no firm conclusions about the optimal pillow height.” A broad-shouldered side sleeper on Reddit put the problem this way: “nobody explains how to actually find the right height without buying 10 pillows.” What follows is general product-selection information, not medical advice. If neck, shoulder or arm symptoms persist, see a clinician. The loft printed on the label measures a pillow nobody is lying on.
Why the Label’s Loft Number Is Not the Loft You Sleep On
A pillow’s labelled loft is its height with nothing resting on it. Banner Health defines loft as the height “when it lays flat on the bed.” Purple, a pillow maker, describes it as thickness “before any weight rests upon it”. Neither number tells you where your head will end up, because the fill gives way as soon as you lie down.
Banner gives its own example: a high-loft pillow “might not hold your head as high as you’d expect if it is very soft and sinks under your weight.” Purple’s guide goes further and says an 8-inch (20 cm) pillow “may compress to just a few inches.” A small laboratory study gives a measured case. In a 2025 trial with 10 participants, the researchers report that wool and memory-foam pillows 14–15 cm (5.5–5.9 in) tall on the shelf sat within 7–11 cm (2.8–4.3 in) once a head and neck rested on them.
Call that second number loaded loft: the height at the pillow’s centre while a stated weight sits on it. It is the number that decides fit, and neither definition above accounts for it. Researchers have the same problem. The 2021 review warns that because foam and buckwheat can be compressed, study results based on stated pillow heights “may be misleading and unreliable.” It also suggests that pillows designed from body measurements need extra height to make up for what they lose under compression.
Why can’t you compare loft labels between brands?
Low, medium and high loft are not standard sizes. SleepWorld puts low loft at 3 in (7.6 cm) or less, medium at 3–5 in (7.6–12.7 cm) and high at anything over 5 in. Purple calls 5.5 in (14 cm) or less low, 5.5–6.5 in (14–16.5 cm) mid, and 6.5–7.5 in (16.5–19 cm) high. Going by those two scales, a 5.5-inch (14 cm) pillow is high loft at one seller and low loft at the other.
Consumer Reports makes the same point about firmness and sleeper-type claims. A label saying a pillow is firm or made for side sleepers “doesn’t mean it’s the right support for you,” so CR suggests pressing the pillow with your palm to about half its thickness to feel how hard it pushes back. For loft, the equivalent is measuring loaded height yourself, using the load test in the worksheet section below.
Measure Your Shoulder Gap Before You Shop
Your shoulder gap is the space a pillow has to fill between your head and the mattress when you lie on your side. In a 2016 ergonomics study, Cai and Chen set out the geometry. Pillow height for side lying should be based on the distance between the ear and the shoulder, and height for back lying on the distance between the back of the head and the upper back. Your mattress changes the side-lying figure. Consumer Reports explains that a softer mattress lets your body sink in, which leaves less of a gap between head and mattress, while a firmer one leaves a larger gap to fill.
That is why two measurements work better than one. The first gives your shoulder width with no mattress involved. The second captures the gap your own bed actually leaves. A side sleeper on the Sleep Doctor community forum described the goal in similar terms, writing that they “needed a pillow that could properly support the gap between my neck and shoulder” and that soft pillows hadn’t worked for them.
Step 1: Measure your ear-to-shoulder width standing
Stand side-on to a wall with the outer point of your shoulder touching it and your head upright. Have someone measure straight out from the wall to the side of your head at ear level, and record the figure in both centimetres and inches. This roughly matches the ear-to-shoulder width that Lei and colleagues’ review lists as the body dimension that supports the head in side lying.
Treat this number as a ceiling, not a target. The same review notes that people lying on their side tend to turn their shoulders forward toward the mattress, and the mattress also takes up some of the shoulder’s depth.
Step 2: Measure the gap on your own mattress
Lie on your side on your own mattress, in your usual position, with no pillow. Slide a stack of books under your head, adding or removing one at a time until your head looks level with your spine. One commenter suggested this method in an r/Pillows thread, with a helper watching or a selfie to check the angle. They added that it “isn’t perfect” because pillows sink a bit, but it gives a starting point. Purple offers a quick way to read the result for side sleepers: if the top of your head drops toward the mattress, the support is too low, and if it angles upward, it’s too high.
Record two heights: the lowest stack where your head still looks level, and the highest stack before your head starts to tip upward. Those two numbers are your target loaded-loft range for side sleeping. Subtracting the middle of that range from your standing width shows roughly how far your shoulder sinks into this particular mattress. If you also sleep on your back, repeat the check with the books under the back of your head and record that height separately.
How far can a body measurement take you?
Cai and Chen measured 40 adults and derived design heights of 14.8 cm (5.8 in) for men and 11.5 cm (4.5 in) for women in side lying, and 3.7 cm (1.5 in) and 2.5 cm (1.0 in) in back lying. Those are group figures for a pillow design, not personal prescriptions.
Not all researchers agree that body size predicts pillow height. Lei and colleagues report that two research groups (Erfanian and colleagues, and Wang and colleagues) found no statistically significant link between body measurements and preferred pillow height. The review suggests the disagreement may come from measuring different things: body mass index, neck length and neck width rather than ear-to-shoulder width. So your own lying measurement is a better starting point than a chart, but the final test is how your head sits on a real pillow.
How Fill Type Decides Whether Loft Survives the Night
Fill type decides how much of a pillow’s shelf height is left once your head is on it, and whether that height comes back after a night. In a randomized laboratory trial, 95 side sleepers rested for 10 minutes each on polyester, feather, latex, regular foam and contoured foam pillows, with depths from 115 to 142 mm (4.5–5.6 in). The slopes of the neck segments differed significantly between pillows, most clearly between feather and the foam and latex pillows. The authors concluded that spinal segment slope “alters significantly” when people switch from a foam, latex or polyester pillow to a feather one, or the other way round.
Not every study points the same way. A 2021 meta-analysis concluded there “may be no change” in side-lying neck alignment “regardless of the use of rubber or feather pillows,” and that alignment may depend more on a pillow’s shape and height. The 2025 trial found no considerable comfort or muscle-activity difference between wool and memory-foam pillows of the same shape. One reading fits both findings: fill matters mainly through the height it holds under load, which is exactly what loaded loft measures. That is also why there is no single best pillow fill in the abstract. Banner Health says no fill material “works best for everyone.”
| Fill | Reported behaviour under load | What to check in hand |
|---|---|---|
| Polyester fibre | Consumer Reports found these pillows “don’t hold their shape well,” so you may replace them more often | Compress it, fluff it, and see whether it returns to its original thickness with the fill evenly spread |
| Solid memory foam | CR says it is denser than polyester and conforms to the head. Linens Delight, a pillow maker, says some solid foam resists compression strongly | It can’t be fluffed to reset, so measure its loaded loft directly |
| Shredded memory foam | Banner Health says it is easier to adjust for a softer feel | Whether you can remove or add fill to move the loaded loft |
| Latex | CR, drawing on its latex mattress tests, says latex has more spring and returns to shape faster after compression | Press and release, and watch how quickly it rebounds |
| Down | CR says down “generally makes for a soft pillow that flattens easily” | Fill weight on the label, plus a loaded-loft reading |
| Feather | CR says feather pillows are usually firmer than down and advises testing how well the pillow holds its shape before buying | Whether it holds its shape after you press it |
| Buckwheat | CR says some people like how it conforms, while others find it too noisy or stiff | Whether you can remove hulls to set the height |
Individual posters describe the same contrast in plain terms. In an r/Pillows thread, one commenter wrote that buckwheat “doesn’t ever sink and go flat.” In an r/Bedding thread about finding lower pillows, one person said a soft down pillow “squishes down nicely,” and another said they deliberately bought pillows that reviewers complained “went flat too quickly.” Losing loft is a defect for one sleeper and the goal for another. That’s why your measured range matters more than any fill’s reputation.
Fill weight, fill power and the kitchen scale
Fill weight is the mass of filling inside the shell, in grams or ounces. Fill power applies to down. CR describes it as “the amount of space that an ounce of down takes up,” and Down Under Bedding, a down retailer, says it applies only to down and “is unregulated by standard.”
Sources disagree on what fill power does to firmness. Consumer Reports says that the higher the number, “the longer it will stay firm.” Down Under Bedding says higher fill power makes a pillow softer and that firmness “is determined by the fill weight.” Two other makers point the same way on quantity: Linens Delight says down pillows can be made firmer by increasing the fill weight, and Purple says “the more fill a pillow has, the firmer it will feel.” These are manufacturers’ statements, not independent tests. Taken together, they suggest that for the same fill and shell size, more fill weight means a firmer pillow.
A kitchen scale lets you check quantity yourself. Weighing a whole pillow gives the gross weight: filling plus shell. Testing labs treat the filling alone as a separate measurement; IDFL’s pillow testing packages list net filling weight separately from loft height and compression and recovery. At home, you can only compare like with like if you weigh loose fill from an adjustable pillow, or compare two pillows with similar shells and the same fill type. A gram of down and a gram of latex do very different jobs.
What IFD or ILD numbers can tell you
Some foam pillows quote an IFD (indentation force deflection) figure, also called ILD (indentation load deflection). According to TestResources, the standard method in ASTM D3574 measures the force needed to push an 8-inch (20 cm) indentor into a foam sample to a set percentage of its height, commonly 25% and 65%. The same source warns that values change if the sample’s thickness or size is different. Because a pillow’s own height is part of the test conditions, IFD figures from pillows of different heights, or with unstated test setups, can’t be compared directly.
Build Your Loft-Matching Worksheet
The worksheet turns your measurements, sleeping position, body weight and a candidate pillow’s fill into one comparison: does this pillow’s loaded loft land inside your range at your test load? Fill it in once for yourself, then add lines 7–10 for each pillow you consider.
| Line | What to record | How to get it | Your entry |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | Main sleeping position, and the position you usually fall asleep in | Your own habit | |
| 2 | Standing ear-to-shoulder width (cm / in) | Step 1 in the shoulder-gap section | |
| 3 | Side-sleeping range, lowest to highest level stack (cm / in) | Step 2 on your own mattress | |
| 4 | Back-sleeping stack height, if you sleep on your back (cm / in) | Step 2 repeated on your back | |
| 5 | Shoulder sink: line 2 minus the middle of line 3 | Subtraction | |
| 6 | Body weight and test load (kg / lb) | Body weight × 0.068, explained below | |
| 7 | Candidate pillow: fill type, labelled loft, fill weight | Label, plus kitchen scale where possible | |
| 8 | Candidate’s uncompressed loft (cm / in) | Load test, step 2 | |
| 9 | Candidate’s loaded loft at 1 minute and 10 minutes (cm / in) | Load test, step 5 | |
| 10 | Match: is line 9 inside line 3 (or line 4)? | Comparison |
How to run the load test
- Fluff the pillow fully and lay it flat on a table. This is the same starting point the Linens Delight home firmness test uses.
- Measure the height at the centre. That is the uncompressed loft for line 8.
- Make up your test load from line 6, using bags of rice or water bottles weighed on the kitchen scale.
- Put a 6-inch (15 cm) plate in the centre of the pillow and set the load on it.
- Measure from the table to the top of the plate and subtract the plate’s thickness. Take one reading after 1 minute and another after 10 minutes. The 10-minute reading follows the rest period used in the side-lying pillow trial, which was based on earlier work finding that neck position needed about 10 minutes to stabilise on a firm surface.
- Write the load, the plate size and both times next to your results, so later readings on the same pillow can be compared.
The line 6 multiplier comes from body-segment data. ExRx’s table of de Leva’s 1996 figures puts the head and neck at an average of 6.81% of body mass (6.94% for men, 6.68% for women). On that basis, a 60 kg (132 lb) sleeper’s reference load is about 4.1 kg (9.0 lb), an 80 kg (176 lb) sleeper’s is about 5.4 kg (12.0 lb), and a 100 kg (220 lb) sleeper’s is about 6.8 kg (15.0 lb). A flat plate on a table is not your head on a mattress. Use the load to compare pillows with each other, not as a measurement of the force your head puts on a pillow in bed.
Reference heights by sleeping position
Published figures help you sanity-check your own range, but they spread widely, especially for back sleeping.
| Position | Published reference heights | Where sources disagree | Worksheet note |
|---|---|---|---|
| Side | Cai and Chen: 11.5 cm (4.5 in) for women, 14.8 cm (5.8 in) for men. In a 21-person foam pillow study, 10 cm (3.9 in) was rated most comfortable of 5, 10 and 14 cm (2.0, 3.9, 5.5 in) | Lei and colleagues cite two research groups that found body measurements didn’t predict preferred height | Use your line 3 range |
| Back | Cai and Chen: 2.5 cm (1.0 in) for women, 3.7 cm (1.5 in) for men, plus a neck rest of about 3 cm (1.2 in). A 16-person radiograph study recommended 10 cm (3.9 in), and its authors say this “is not an absolute figure” | The figures run from 2.5 to 10 cm (1.0–3.9 in), and Lei’s review reports another study favouring 7 cm (2.8 in) | Use line 4 |
| Stomach | Business Insider says low-loft pillows “usually” measure under 3 in (7.6 cm). Consumer Reports advises a thin pillow that doesn’t push the neck up too high | Lei’s review notes the prone position was “barely evaluated” in the studies it covered | Run Step 2 face-down if you sleep this way |
| Combination | CR: choose firmness based on the position you fall asleep in. Banner Health: consider adjustable fill | Published side and back figures sit far apart | Record both line 3 and line 4 |
The pillow for back sleepers ends up much lower than the side-sleeping figure in every source that gives both. The pillow for stomach sleepers is the least studied of the three, so your own face-down check carries more weight there than any published number.
Adjust for your mattress, body weight and position changes
Your line 3 range already reflects your mattress, because you measured it on that bed. Redo it if you change mattresses or add a topper. Banner Health describes the mattress link in terms of firmness rather than height, suggesting a firmer pillow may suit a softer mattress. That advice is about a different property from CR’s height guidance. The lying measurement avoids the conflict by recording the gap your mattress actually leaves.
Body weight changes what happens on the pillow. Using the de Leva figure, a 100 kg sleeper’s reference load is about 2.7 kg (6.0 lb) heavier than a 60 kg sleeper’s, so the same soft pillow will sit lower under them. Purple, speaking about its own range, says heavier people feel more supported with a higher-loft or firmer pillow. Running the load test at your own weight builds that adjustment in. Seen this way, the firm vs soft pillow question becomes narrower: which firmness puts the loaded loft inside your range at your load?
Changing position overnight is the hardest case. In Cai and Chen’s sleep-position study, 40 participants changed position an average of 24.2 times a night, and the authors found existing pillows too high for back lying and too low for side lying. Their answer was a U-shaped design, lower in the middle and higher at the sides. Lei’s review points out that this kind of design can’t make sure people lie in the right zone. Adjustable fill is the more flexible route. CR reports that adjustable pillows tend to perform better than others in its tests. The Business Insider tester, who sleeps on both stomach and side, added a little extra fill to an adjustable pillow so it worked in both positions. On the worksheet, aim for line 3 or line 4 depending on the position you fall asleep in, and note how much fill hits each.
Test the Pillow You Already Own
A pillow that no longer suits you has either worn out or was never the right height for you, and each problem has a different fix. The checks below tell them apart using your worksheet numbers.
Step 1: Check whether it recovers
For fibre, down, feather and shredded fills, use the fold test that Cleveland Clinic sleep specialist Brian Chen, MD, describes. Fold the pillow in half. If it bounces back, that’s a good sign; if it “stays folded or goes flat,” it’s probably time for a new one. He also lists lumps and a dent where your head lies as warning signs, and says most pillows “usually need to be replaced within a year or two.”
Solid foam and latex need a different check. The Business Insider tester noted that a medium-firm memory foam pillow can’t be folded. Instead, use Consumer Reports’ approach: press the pillow to about half its thickness with your palm, let go, and see whether it returns to its original shape and thickness. With loose fills, also check that the filling is spread evenly.
Step 2: Re-measure its loaded loft
Run the load test with the same load and plate you recorded on the worksheet. Compare the uncompressed loft with the labelled loft, or with your own earlier reading if you have one. Then compare the 10-minute loaded loft with your line 3 or line 4 range.
Step 3: Read the result
| Recovery check | Loaded loft vs your range | Likely meaning | Next step |
|---|---|---|---|
| Passes | Inside | Height is probably not the problem | Look at other factors. Dr. Chen advises seeing a physician if discomfort continues after a pillow change |
| Passes | Outside | Wrong height for you | Adjust the fill if you can. Otherwise, shop with your worksheet |
| Fails | Inside | Worn, and the height will keep drifting | Plan a replacement with similar loaded loft |
| Fails | Outside | Worn, and possibly the wrong height too | Replace it, and test candidates against your range |
Adjusting works better in one direction than the other. As one commenter in the r/Pillows thread put it, an adjustable pillow that’s too high lets you remove filling, but one that’s too low “is harder to fix without buying more filling.”
Use the trial period as a measuring window
Consumer Reports says you may not get a full sense of an adjustable pillow until you’ve slept on it for about a month, and suggests adjusting the fill every few days. When you check whether your head looks level, give it time. In a study of 24 young women lying on their side on a polyester pillow, 70.8% had a stable neck position by 15 minutes, so take your photo after you’ve been still for roughly that long.
Feel alone can mislead you. Lei and colleagues note that a habitual pillow height can feel comfortable while still holding the neck in an incorrect position, and that a new height can take time to get used to. Getting used to a pillow can change how its height feels, but it doesn’t change the height itself, so let the loaded-loft reading decide whether a pillow is in your range.
Trial lengths in Consumer Reports’ coverage ranged from 30 to 100 nights, and CR notes that not every maker or retailer offers returns. Check the terms before you buy, and run your measurements well before the deadline.
What to Look For First
Look first at the height a pillow holds under your head, because the loft on the label is measured with nothing on it and the low, medium and high bands vary by seller. Before shopping, measure your own lying gap on your own mattress, record the range on the worksheet, and judge every candidate by its loaded loft at your test load, with fill type and fill weight explaining where it lands. Buy within a return window you’ve checked, so the level-head check at home gets the final say. As Cleveland Clinic’s Brian Chen put it, “it’s not more expensive is better. It’s what fits your body.”
Frequently Asked Questions
How long should I give a new pillow before deciding?
For adjustable pillows, Consumer Reports says you may need about a month, adjusting the fill every few days. Each time, check whether your head looks level after about 15 minutes of lying still.
Can a stomach sleeper skip the pillow entirely?
Sleep consultant Kelly Murray told Business Insider that some stomach sleepers should consider going without a pillow. She cautioned that it isn’t for everyone, especially combination sleepers, so try it before you get rid of your pillow.
Is a more expensive pillow worth it?
Banner Health says a good, long-lasting pillow may cost between US$25 and US$100, and that price can sometimes reflect quality. Cleveland Clinic’s Brian Chen says fit matters more than price.