
No standard measurement for “normal” sag exists across multiple mattress manufacturers. Each company’s warranty defines “normal” sag differently. As of October 11, 2026, eight different policies were analyzed. The shallowest sag allowed by Tempur-Pedic’s warranty is >1.9cm [.75’] whereas the deepest allowed by Avocado’s Organic Luxury Plush is >5.1cm [2’]. All sags shallower than what is stated in manufacturer’s warranty are considered normal wear within the warranty.
Manufacturer warranties are issued for an empty mattress, however, the weight placed on the mattress will cause you to feel the sag within the mattress. For example, a study conducted with thirty-two (32) used innerspring beds revealed that though the innerspring springs were comparable in length when unloaded compared to the loaded springs, the loaded springs compressed down to the same height with a much greater degree of compression. Remember that this is simply general information for consumers; thus, consumers should determine their actual limits on how they would rate wear of their mattress before filing a warranty or giving up.
How Much Sag Is Normal in a Mattress? The Answer Is Written in Your Policy
The term “normal”, with respect to warranty coverage of a mattress, is defined as being below the warranty threshold outlined in that policy. The warranty threshold indicates how deep the indentations must be to qualify as a defect under the policy terms. As referenced in the articles reviewed, the warranty threshold is defined as follows: Tempur-Pedic = 0.75-inch minimum; Casper = 1-inch minimum; Purple = 1-inch minimum; Saatva = 1.5-in minimum; Avocado = at or above 1.5-in minimum coverage. In the UK, Emma = 2.5cm or more; Koala = 2.5cm or above.
As a result of these definitions, there are significant differences between the manufacturer policies outlined in the articles on warranty coverage for mattresses—specifically, the maximum policy coverage ranges from greater than 0.75 inch for Tempur-Pedic to greater than 1.5 inches for Saatva. The warranty definition referenced above for the majority of manufacturers does not agree with the 2022 journal paper that states “the predominance of mattress manufacturers” have a warranty policy requirement that would indicate 1.5 inches as a threshold.
To create your own warranty threshold, you will need three pieces of information.
- Purchase date. Tempur-Pedic’s warranty index lists separate mattress texts for purchases from October 1, 2022 onward, for March 1, 2014 to October 1, 2022, and for purchases before March 2014.
- Model. Avocado sets a deeper line for one model. Tempur-Pedic’s help center says quilted tops need more than 1.5 in and non-quilted models more than 0.75 in, but the current warranty document doesn’t make that split. If you own a quilted Tempur-Pedic, ask the company in writing which rule applies.
- Market. Each text in the table below applies to one country or region.
One example of an edge case to keep in mind is that Purple states the indentation must be “greater than one (1.00) inch” to qualify for warranty coverage and does not cover any indents “less than 1.0”. Therefore, the warranty coverage for an indentation that measures exactly 1.0 inch is not covered by either warranty clause.
What a Depth Threshold Measures, and What It Was Never Built to See
A threshold measures one thing: how deep a dip looks with nobody on the bed. Tempur-Pedic measures “without applying weight or pressure” and Purple “after full recovery from load”. Avocado requires the dip to be visible “when no weight is applied”.
These manufacturers all state that their measurements do not include any changes in feel or experience from normal use. Example: Tempur-Pedic explicitly states that they will not include any change in comfort preference; Purple lists local firmness changes as something typical and excludes them; Emma lists standard softening as something outside the normal experience; and Casper and Koala both exclude a regular increase in comfort.
Research is showing that depth and feel are not as closely correlated in many situations. Jacobson and colleagues conducted a study of springs from 32 innerspring mattresses that had been used for 6–12 years. When unloaded, the average height of a spring from a mattress in the centre was 12.2 cm and a spring from the end was 12.6 cm (the difference was negligible). With the same 1,296 g weight added, the centre springs were compressed 2.78 cm and the end springs 1.52 cm. The authors inferred that weakening of springs may not be visually apparent when an empty bed is viewed. This study only examined springs.
In a 2024 laboratory durability test, foam performed similarly to the 2023 test: All “Foam” tests used only one sample each to represent the foam’s durability. The polyurethane foam mattress experienced approximately 28% reduction in hardness after the first 7,500 rolling cycles, and after completing 90,000 rolling cycles the foam mattress lost a maximum of 3.79 mm of height. The authors of the current study state that they consider the foam stable following this initial loss of hardness. These two previous studies suggest that some worn-out materials may provide lower support long before they lose enough height to reach the ASTM depth line. However, this conclusion was drawn solely based on the limited number of samples, thus it is not yet confirmed by a comprehensive test with multiple samples.
The ASTM F1566 test cannot provide an approval or disapproval rating. The scope of ASTM F1566 states that it provides data for “comparison analysis with no pass or fail criteria.” Additionally, since ASTM F1566 is designed for materials freshly manufactured, equipment used to determine durability must meet certain requirements of ASTM F1566.
Sag Thresholds Compared: Eight Policy Texts Across Four Markets
Below the following table is an outline of each text’s threshold, the measuring instructions for each text, as well as the rules that govern each text in a basic manner. Each of these texts was reviewed on October 11, 2026. As referenced in the table, the actual terms may vary, so always refer back to your own text to confirm any row.
| Policy text | Covered depth | Measuring condition stated | Base rule highlights |
|---|---|---|---|
| Tempur-Pedic 10-Year Limited (US, bought from Oct 1, 2022) | More than 1.9 cm [0.75 in] | “Without applying weight or pressure” | Slats at least 7.6 cm [3 in] wide and no more than 10.2 cm [4 in] apart. Plywood and bunkie boards listed as inadequate |
| Tempur-Pedic 10-Year Full Replacement (US, bought Mar 1, 2014 to Oct 1, 2022) | More than 1.9 cm [0.75 in] | None stated | Center support and 5–6 legs for queen and up. 3-beam support recommended on slatted frames |
| Casper 10-Year Limited (US and Canada) | More than 2.5 cm [1 in] | None stated | Matching foundation or adjustable base |
| Purple 10-Year Limited (US) | More than 2.5 cm [1.00 in] | After full recovery from load, compared with surrounding areas. Cover stays on | Slats no more than 8.9 cm [3.5 in] apart. Proof of support since purchase |
| Saatva Friends for Life (continental US) | More than 3.8 cm [1.5 in] | None stated | Slats less than 10.2 cm [4 in] apart, plus center support for queen and up |
| Avocado claim page (US) | 3.8 cm [1.5 in] or more. Organic Luxury Plush: 5.1 cm [2 in] or more | No weight. Taut string across full width, measured to the deepest point, on the floor or a solid platform | Third-party slats at least 6.4 cm [2.5 in] wide and no more than 12.7 cm [5 in] apart |
| Emma UK guarantee, clause 19 (UK) | More than 2.5 cm | “Visible to the naked eye” and permanent | Dip must occur “despite correct usage” |
| Koala 10-Year Limited (Australia, direct purchase) | More than 2.5 cm | None stated | Matching foundation or adjustable base |
There are three notable patterns in the table. First, Avocado is the only text that includes an inclusion criterion for a dip that is equal to the line. All other texts require that the dip is greater than the line. Second, only three of the texts contain how to measure the dips and they do not use the same terminology for doing so. Therefore, if a row states that no measuring instructions were provided in the text reviewed, that does not mean any method to measuring will be acceptable for your text. Third, Tempur-Pedic, Casper and Koala all have nearly identical wording regarding the Foundation portion of their texts. The next part of this article discusses why that clause is important to understand.
Mattress Body Impression, Sagging in the Middle, or a Failing Base?
Some settling is part of how a mattress works, according to the brands themselves. Saatva says “certain body impressions… are to be expected” as the mattress adapts to you. Avocado says its wool layer compresses where you sleep and calls that expected behavior, not damage. A body impression only becomes a claim once it’s deeper than your policy’s line.
When examining a body impression, the dip shape may provide some first indication. A Mumsnet reviewer from the UK noted that their Emma mattress has a “dip on both sides and is nice and firm in the middle”. When viewed in combination with the two sleeper-shaped troughs that have formed, it can only indicate a problem with the mattress itself, and the reviewer later got a replacement. However, when examining a large mattress, like a queen or king, with a large ground-level trough down the center, further investigation into the foundation of the mattress is critical. According to Avocado, “if your frame does not support the middle of the mattress, it will visibly sag, causing the mattress to wear unevenly”. The statement also suggests that most claims will be denied for lack of proper support.
Recognizing shared clauses among various mattress manufacturers should help you understand their warranty coverage. For example, Tempur-Pedic, Casper and Koala state that any sagging or indentation falling outside of what is described as not having a matching or suitable support base are not warranted. Traditional wear of your mattress requires it to continuously be in contact with the manufacturer recommended foundation or adjustable bed frame or the company has no warranty coverage on it. If you find this language in your warrant policy, the first item an inspector will check is your support system.
Different manufacturers have a different definition of a proper supporting foundation for their products. Currently, Tempur-Pedic’s current text states that support from plywood is not sufficient, while Saatva currently recommends plywood or similar solid foundation type support for their HD models, while on their Zenhaven models require the use of plywood.
Here’s how to check your base:
- Legs and center support. Count the legs and confirm there’s a center support. Purple and Tempur-Pedic both specify 5–6 legs for queen and larger.
- Slats. Measure slat width and gaps against your row in the table.
- Base surface. Lift the mattress and lay a straightedge across the bare base. If the base dips, the mattress on top has been following it.
How to Measure Mattress Sag the Way Your Warranty Will Judge It
The instructions outlined in this guide combine and reflect the policies which outline these instructions. This guide provides a home equivalent to the measurement of your mattress. The measurements are not lab tests, nor do they supersede your policy’s wording.
Step 1 — Read your policy first for any information on cover, surface and load support. If you find no references to any of these, you can ask the manufacturer directly via email, for free.
Step 2 — Strip off any bedding before checking the cover policy. Purple states in all capital letters “DO NOT REMOVE MATTRESS COVER,” indicating that removing it will void your warranty. Tempur-Pedic requires you to keep the original cover on the mattress at all times. Avocado says to measure a “fully stripped mattress,” but does not clarify whether to include the cover or not, so be sure to contact Avocado directly before doing anything else.
Step 3 — Allow the mattress to recover without weight upon it. Purple states measuring must occur “after full recovery from load,” but none of the texts state how many minutes or hours that may take. To measure the mattress immediately after getting up does not comply with the wording above.
Establish a rigid reference line. Avocado states to establish a taut line using string across the entire width, or to use straight edges like wood rulers or levels, all of which Tempur-Pedic has stated by its help center that straight edges must run from one end of the affected area to the other.
In step 5 of this process, it is important for you to find the deepest part of your mattress and NOT average the results. As Avocado has stated, the measurement is taken from the deepest indentation, and this is found at the centre line (middle of the tufting). Averaging multiple measurements will give you a number that is smaller than that of the deepest point measurement. Another company that produces mattresses, Stearns & Foster, which is NOT one of the eight that this article discusses, states that customers must NOT push the ruler down into the mattress when measuring. Another company, Tempur-Pedic states that if a part does not stand up on its own at the deepest indentation, it is usually a sign that the deepest indentation does not have enough depth, but ultimately, your straightedge reading will determine if there has been any sagging.
Step 6 is to measure the surface area of the mattress as described by the manufacturer’s warranty. The manufacturer’s warranty states that if measuring on the floor for Avocado, a solid platform is a must; if measuring on slats or a box spring, you may be measuring the sag in other components of the bed. Additionally, Avocado states that if you are measuring on the floor, it voids the warranty; therefore, you should not sleep on the floor until you have your mattress measured.
Step 7 is to document the measurements in the same format that the reviewers will use for their information. For example, when taking photographs, be sure to take a picture with the straightedge captured in full view on both ends, so that the ruler markings are easily visible. As stated by Stearns & Foster and Tempur-Pedic, please remember to take a picture of the broom handle shown in a straight line from end to end. Also make notations of the date of when you were measuring and for how long the bed has been empty before measuring; and the direction that the reference line runs on the mattress. Avocado has only listed one direction of measurement; the width; therefore, if you have a lengthwise measurement, please list that separately; it would be additional proof.
A woman from Mumsnet reported that she received a new mattress after she sent in photos using “both weights and a spirit level.” She claims that Tempur-Pedic and Avocado have a “no weighted photos” policy set within their terms of service. Therefore, she encourages anyone who uses weighted photos for their Claims to keep these as supplemental information and instead use only the full set of empty bed measurements for the claim.
Height loss is a separate clause, not a sag claim. Purple covers changes in mattress size only above 2 in, and Emma allows a 2 cm leeway when a new mattress expands out of its packaging.
The Exclusions That Sink a Claim Before Anyone Checks the Depth
If you fail to meet a prior condition when you submit a claim, a deep, well-measured dip can still be denied. This article groups the terms of the policy into different sections. However, the order of which each reviewer works through the terms is not specified in any of the texts you have read.
- Who bought it, and from whom. Every text read limits coverage to the original purchaser. Tempur-Pedic’s 2014–2022 text excludes sales by unauthorized resellers on third-party websites, naming Craigslist, eBay and Amazon as examples. Emma names Amazon as an approved retailer. Casper asks owners who bought from another retailer to register to activate the warranty.
- Where the mattress is. Purple’s warranty is void if the mattress is used outside the USA. Saatva covers only the continental US, and Emma excludes mattresses transported outside the UK.
- The base, from day one. Purple requires proof of a sufficient foundation and frame “since purchase”, used without interruption. Tempur-Pedic may ask for proof of the base’s quality.
- Stains and hygiene. Saatva’s warranty doesn’t apply to a mattress that “has been stained”. Casper and Koala exclude stain damage only where “the defect is caused by such abuse or damage”. Tempur-Pedic and Purple both reserve the right to deny a mattress in unsanitary condition.
- Tags and cover. Purple requires law tags to be intact and warns that removing the cover may void the warranty.
- Care rules. Avocado requires head-to-toe rotation monthly for the first six months, then every other month. It also requires a boxed mattress to be opened within 30 days. Emma excludes damage from not unboxing within four weeks.
- Use. Purple’s warranty is void if the mattress is used by a medical patient or kept in storage.
Adding anything to the dip before claiming it will create another issue with your claim. For example, adding a piece of plywood under your mattress as a base is a listed inadequate base under Tempur-Pedic’s existing text. If you are going to add a board, topper, or frame, take photos of what your existing setup looks like before you make that modification.
Mattress Sag Warranty Claim Checklist: Measurements, Photos, Paperwork
This checklist combines the claim requirements published by Tempur-Pedic, Purple, Avocado, Emma, Saatva, Casper and Stearns & Foster. Your own brand’s list always takes priority.
Before you measure
- [ ] Find the warranty text that matches your purchase date, model and country, and save a copy.
- [ ] Confirm your base meets that text’s leg, center-support and slat rules, and photograph it before changing anything.
- [ ] Check the cover rule and the measuring surface (Steps 2 and 6 above).
Measurement record
- [ ] Take empty-bed readings with a rigid straightedge or taut string at the deepest point, without pressing down.
- [ ] Log the date, how long the bed was empty, and the direction of each reading. Keep the widthwise reading as your main one.
Photo set
- [ ] Take a full view of the mattress without bedding. Tempur-Pedic and Stearns & Foster both ask for this.
- [ ] Take a close-up of the dip with the whole straightedge and a readable ruler in frame.
- [ ] Photograph the base, foundation or frame. Purple also asks for photos showing overall cleanliness.
- [ ] Photograph the law tag, even if it’s faded. One Emma owner had to send a photo of her blank, washed-out label.
Paperwork and submission
- [ ] Find a receipt or bank statement; Tempur-Pedic accepts either. Have your order number ready for Purple.
- [ ] Write a short statement describing the damage, as Tempur-Pedic’s current text requires. Tempur-Pedic also asks you to report “as soon as possible after discovery.”
- [ ] Send the claim in writing. Saatva requires written notice, and Which? advises UK buyers to write to the retailer so there’s a record.
- [ ] For Emma, ask customer service how they want the fault photographed, as clause 19.4 sets out.
What an Approved Claim Actually Gets You
In most cases when the Customer has received Company Approval, a Replacement or Repair will be completed by the Company, not a Refund, and the costs associated with the Repair/Replacement are incurred.
- Tempur-Pedic (current text): You pay transport costs, capped at standard freight. If an inspector visits, you pay the fee up front and get it back if the claim is covered. You must hand over the original mattress or pay full price for the replacement (source).
- Purple: You pay transport for claims made after 100 days. The replacement may feel different and doesn’t come with a new sleep trial (source).
- Casper: You don’t pay shipping costs to return the mattress (source).
- Saatva: Years 1–2 get a free replacement. From year 3, Saatva repairs and re-covers the mattress for a $149 fee, or you can choose a new mattress for $99 plus 50%, 60% or 80% of the original retail price, depending on the year (source).
- Avocado (25-year models): Years 1–10 are not prorated. From year 11 you pay a share of the original price, starting at 50% and rising 5% a year, plus shipping (source).
- Emma: A replacement is shipped, the faulty mattress is collected free, and you get a full refund if the model is discontinued (source).
- Koala: You get a replacement mattress or cover, with no return shipping cost (source).
For example, Tempur-Pedic, Purple, Casper, Avocado and Emma all state that when a Company replaces your defective items with new items, the warranty for the original purchase does not terminate; the warranty period continues on from the original purchase date. In order to give you an example of how this would work: If you purchased a mattress from Emma and after five years the mattress has developed a fault and needed to be replaced with a new one. The new mattress would continue to have five additional years of warranty coverage on it; it would not receive a new five-year warranty on the replacement mattress. Therefore, prior to filing your Claim, you should understand that the determination as to whether it is cost-effective to file a Claim may depend on the various Fees associated with filing a Claim and how many years you have owned the item.
When It Feels Sunken but Measures Under the Line
Here’s an explanation of this gap in the contract language. A moderator on Mattress Underground expressed that “Virtual impressions,” which you can detect by touch but not with your eyes, “are excluded from the warranty.” The moderator attributed this to the initial softening of foam produced from less quality, lower density materials. Because this opinion is based on one moderator’s experience and is not a specific test result, buyers should consider checking foam density rather than relying on it as a guarantee.
Buyers have other options available. Start a dated log so you can tell whether the dip is getting deeper:
| Date | Empty-bed depth (method, direction) | How it feels with weight on it | Base check |
|---|---|---|---|
| Example | 1.4 cm, string across width | Rolling toward the middle | Slats and legs photographed |
The empty bed column in the contract is the only column that reflects an actual warranty. The other columns are your own comparison notes.
The written warranty does not necessarily have to be the only means of addressing a problem.
- United States. The FTC explains that state law creates implied warranties. Claims for breach generally have to be brought within four years of purchase, and the product must be of “normal durability, considering its nature and price.” Implied warranties don’t cover ordinary wear. A limited warranty can also cut their length down to its own term, as Purple’s and Tempur-Pedic’s texts do.
- United Kingdom. A manufacturer’s guarantee “does not replace or limit” your statutory rights against the retailer, and Emma’s own clause 19.1 says the same. Which? notes you have up to six years to take a claim to court (five in Scotland). After the first six months, though, it’s up to you to show the fault was there when the mattress was delivered.
- Other markets. Australian and Canadian consumer law weren’t reviewed here.
The Check That Changes the Decision
There are three things to be aware of for the final check: check if your base is compliant with your warranty document, review the specifications as listed in your document for the exact amount, and compare the two readings. If the base is above the maximum outlined in your warranty document, submit a full claim. If the base is below but the mattress seems to have lost support, you should keep a dated record of purchases and check your right to a refund or replacement with the retailer in the UK. If your base is not compliant, you should take action to fix it and take photos of the fixed product before proceeding with any claim or reimbursement.
Frequently Asked Questions
Will I need to remove my mattress cover in order to measure it? It depends on your mattress. For example, Purple states that removing the mattress cover may void the warranty. On the other hand, Avocado has a policy of “fully stripped,” but does not clarify exactly what this means, so make sure to get a written explanation from them prior to purchase.
Is the quarter method an adequate way to measure a mattress? It’s not. Tempur-Pedic’s help center suggests that a quarter standing up means the depression is too shallow, while they say the only accurate way to measure the amount of depression is by using the straightedge method.
Does a replacement mattress come with a fresh warranty?
Usually not. Tempur-Pedic, Purple and Emma keep the original start date. Tempur-Pedic and Casper start a new term only if you pay to upgrade.
If I bought my mattress from Amazon, do I have a warranty? It is dependent upon who your mattress brand is and who sold you the product. For instance, Emma specifically mentions that Amazon is an authorized retailer for their products. As of 2014 through 2022, Tempur-Pedic’s website has a disclaimer that they will not guarantee warranties for mattresses sold on Amazon or other unauthorized resellers on third-party websites.
Will putting plywood under the mattress hurt a claim?
It can. Tempur-Pedic’s current text lists plywood as an inadequate base, while Saatva recommends or requires a solid layer for certain models. Check your own policy first.