Mattresses

How Firm Should a Mattress Be? What the 1-to-10 Scale Measures and What It Leaves Out

When selecting a mattress, the bed should be able to support both the hips and shoulders while not causing the centre to dip. The mattress should also allow your body to feel comfortable when lying down. How firm or soft the mattress feels will depend greatly on your size and sleeping position; therefore most recommendations by testing labs for those in the middle weight range recommend a mattress rated as either Medium or Medium Firm. Neither the manufacturer’s rating nor any manufacturer’s label will accurately represent your individual needs, because there is currently no standardised measurement of mattress firmness across manufacturers, as all mattress companies create their own firmness scale based on their interpretation of firmness and softness. one test lab’s body-weight guidance puts most mid-weight sleepers between medium and medium-firm. There isn’t a standard measurement behind the 1-to-10 firmness scale.

The official 1-10 firmness scale referenced in Europe is simply expressed in a different manner, which runs in the opposite direction. The official EU standard mentions that this rating system cannot be used to establish how comfortable or how high of quality mattresses are. In order to learn which firmness rating will best suit your needs, you may want to establish which firmness bands represent your starting point, and how each individual manufacturer measures their products against these bands. Additionally, you’ll want to create a trial period for trying out different brands and see how you feel after sleeping on their mattress. As with the initial point about learning which firmness rating will work for you, it will also be helpful if you know who measures their firmness ratings.

How Mattress Firmness Is Measured, and by Whom

Firmness is a mechanical quantity that indicates how much force it takes to depress a surface a certain distance. The European standard EN 1957 quantifies firmness by applying pressure to a mattress using a loading pad and plotting the resulting forces against the depth of indentation, resulting in a load/deflection curve. The firmness value is calculated from this curve in newtons per millimetre and a firmness rating is determined through empirical studies.

On this rating scale, a rating of 1 indicates very firm, while a rating of 10 indicates very soft. In fact, on this scale, the “1” rating is the opposite of what most U.S. consumers perceive. The standard is also very clear, stating that the firmness rating “cannot be used to indicate comfort and/or quality of any mattress or bed system.” Further, it states that the results of the testing are only applicable to the specific item tested and that they do not, in general, apply to air beds or water beds.

In addition to the firmness rating, you will also find references to two foams in the specifications; the ASTM D3574 standard tests polyurethane foams, but it states, “the test data apply only under the testing conditions and are not representative of the material’s performance in actual use.” The ISO 2439 standard measures only the indentation hardness of open-cell latex, urethane, and PVC foam; it states, “the data obtained from the ISO 2439 test cannot, in general, be used for design purposes.”

The familiar firmness scale in the United States from 1 to 10 (where 1 is softest and thus 10 the firmest) isn’t defined by any of the three mentioned standards, and in fact, the scope texts for those standards provide no guidance to that scale. Rather, it was created by sellers and reviewers of mattresses. Sleep Doctor states plainly, “A common, universal firmness scale does not exist.” Consequently, it uses its own proprietary firmness scale to classify mattresses. At Sleepopolis, the lead tester assigns a firmness grade based on the agency’s standards, and all testers provide grades based on their own experiences; the average of those individual ratings is used to determine the final grade assigned to each tested mattress. Consumer Reports employs the EN 1957 protocol to develop a firmness rating scale, but reports the lowest rating (grade 1) as “very soft” and the highest rating (grade 10) as “very firm.” An independent testing agency that utilises the European method of defining firmness metrics has found that it requires adjustment when applied to this market.

Why a 6.5 From One Brand Isn’t a 6.5 From Another

Each seller’s categorization system uses different definitions for individual ratings. Therefore, the ratings number is only meaningful when associated with the seller-specific descriptors. A review of the published definitions for four sellers/testers and the European Rating is provided in the following table. It is important to keep in mind that the definitions only are compared in this chart; mattresses are not measured or rated in this comparison.

Scale and market Direction How “medium-firm” or an 8 is defined How the number is set
Purple (US) 1 softest, 10 firmest 6–7 is medium-firm, “suitable for most sleepers”; 8 is firm, “minimal sinkage” Not disclosed on the guide
Simba (UK) 1 extra soft, 10 extra firm 6 is medium firm in its scale list, “between 6-7” later on the same page; 7–8 is firm, “no sinkage” Brand says there’s no standard measurement
Emma India (India) 8 presented as firm-leaning 8/10 described as a “good balance of firmness, support and comfort” Not disclosed on the listing
Sleepopolis (US reviewer) 1 soft, 10 firm 6.5 used “as the standard for medium firm” Averaged ratings from staff testers
EN 1957 firmness rating (Europe) 1 very firm, 10 very soft No consumer feel labels Instrumented load/deflection measurement

A pattern emerges most clearly with the 8 rating. Both Purple and Simba define their 8 rating as firm with minimal sink rate while Emma India defines theirs as “a balanced feel” for its 8 rating. If you read an 8 rating from one brand off of the chart of another brand, you would have a different expectation of the type of bed you would actually receive. The 6.5 = medium-firm figure that appears within reviews is simply the opinion of one reviewer and isn’t a standard defined by any measurement entity.

Brand charts should not be seen as measuring devices, either. For example, the weight table on Simba’s website indicates that “16.4 Stone / 104 Kg” constitutes the upper limit of their middle band and also serves as the lower limit of their top band. Their back-sleeper paragraph uses the statement for side sleepers, “the side sleeper range is between 3 and 8”. While these are only small discrepancies, they help illustrate that the brand charts were developed with marketing purposes in mind, not calibrated for accuracy.

“”” Buyers manually convert these figures into their own measurements. For instance, an individual who was 5 ft 11 inches tall and weighed 187 pounds described the differences between the ratings of various mattresses based on the way he perceived them, saying, “Each company’s scale is going to be different.” In his head, he estimated WinkBed’s designation of Firm to rate approximately 8.5 and Luxury Firm approximately 6 on his mental scale. For him, the Firm designation was too firm and the Luxury Firm designation was too soft; therefore, he wanted something in between. This single person’s review does not establish an overall trend for consumers; however, it does highlight the difficulties mattress shoppers face when labels do not reference the same measuring tool. In one r/Mattress review, he noted that everyone’s scale is different. “””

How Your Weight and Sleep Position Change the Mattress You Feel

The load to deflection curve helps explain why a mattress can feel different to two people at the same time. Heavier bodies exert more force on the mattress surface, which causes deeper sinkage into identical materials than lighter weights. According to the Sleep Foundation’s testing notes, a heavier person will perceive the same mattress to be softer than a lighter person due to this increased force on the mattress. Purple’s guide states that a lighter sleeper may perceive the mattress as firmer than its rating while a heavier sleeper may perceive it as softer.

The location of the force being applied to a mattress is also determined by a person’s sleeping position. When a person sleeps on their side, the majority of their body weight rests on their hip and shoulder; therefore, creating sharper pressure points than a person who sleeps on their back. When an individual sleeps on their stomach, their body weight may cause their midsection to sink sufficiently into a mattress to curve their spine. Consequently, it is recommended that side sleepers use a “softer” mattress than stomach sleepers at identical weights.

You can observe the effects of both types of sleepers using the same mattress. One verified Trustpilot reviewer said the Emma mattress was “plenty of support and had plenty of give,” and attributed the difference in perception of firmness to the weight difference between he and his wife. To accommodate her side sleeping position, the couple purchased an additional soft mattress topper. A second verified buyer of the same mattress stated that the medium-firm mattress was “too soft” for them due to their chronic back pain, and therefore provided a different rating than the other two couples, although they both purchased the same product.

The weight band and its placement categories are based upon testing-laboratory practices and testing-lab conventions as well as guidelines from manufacturers. The ranges for each weight category (under 130 lbs., 130-230 lbs., and over 230 lbs) are not definitive measures; rather, they should serve as a starting point for investigation into product options.

What the Back-Pain Research Actually Tested

The phrase “a medium-firm mattress is the best for your back” has become the most commonly repeated statement in relation to this topic. However, the body of research behind the phrase is narrower than you may realize based on the way it’s been presented. This table presents you with the trial that most of those that prepare guides for consumers rely upon and the two reviews of the research that combine a broader array of literature on this subject.

Study What it did Who it studied What it can’t tell you
Kovacs et al., The Lancet, 2003 Double-blind randomised trial; firm (Hs 2.3) vs medium-firm (Hs 5.6) on the European scale, over 90 days 313 adults with chronic non-specific low-back pain How a pain-free shopper will sleep, or what any brand’s number corresponds to
Radwan et al., Sleep Health, 2015 Systematic review of 24 controlled trials since 2000 Adults with or without back pain Exact firmness, because mattresses were “subjectively identified” as soft, medium-firm, firm, or custom inflated
Caggiari et al., 2021 Systematic review of 39 studies Mixed populations A settled answer; the review opens by calling the literature “discordant”

The Kovacs trial is the strongest single piece of evidence regarding the subject matter covered. The study began with a premise that a firm mattress would “in all likelihood” help alleviate some of the discomfort associated with lower back problems; however there was no supporting evidence to back up that initial assumption. After completing the 90-day period, the participants who used the medium-firm mattress exhibited lower levels of pain in bed and also reduced levels of disability. The gap that exists for pain at the time of rising was found to be between 0.97 and 3.86 according to the confidence interval ranges established by the Kovacs trial. Therefore, based on the range of values produced by the Kovacs trial, it is safe to say that this study did not provide a definitive conclusion regarding the benefits of utilizing a firm mattress.

Take note of the fact that the scale of measurement used in this study was based on the European Mattress Rating Scale (EMRS) system, where a medium-firm mattress received a rating of 5.6, where 10 represents the softest mattress that could be purchased. Therefore, you cannot directly convert the EMRS score to the similar Purple 6 – 7 scale or Sleepopolis 6.5 scale used by either of those products as both of those scales are not defined in relation to the European Mattress Rating system. Neither of the two reviews supports the use of a firm mattress for the treatment of lower back pain. Radwan’s article on Best Mattress for Chronic Back Pain supports the self-adjustment of air mattresses to assist individuals suffering from chronic lower back pain. Their underlying firmness labels were either subjective or tied to the 2000 edition of the standard.

The firmness designations associated with both reviews are either subjective in nature or were assigned to the 2000 edition of the European Mattress Rating Standard, which was changed in 2012. There appears to be growing evidence that indicates individuals suffering from chronic lower back pain should avoid the use of very firm mattresses and should only consider using something in the medium firmness category, as evidenced by the body of research conducted to date. However, this conclusion should not be interpreted as an advertisement for or requirement for using a particular type of mattress. If your back pain persists or is becoming worse, always consult your clinician before relying on a particular mattress or bedding for relief.

Read the Layers, Not Just the Firmness Label

Many materials are made into a large stack which demonstrates the firmness number. This stack is also where the feel comes from. Simba considers firmness to be provided primarily by the comfort layer located on the top of the mattress and from the core for support. Purple’s guide adds that the core provides more support based on its construction, thickness, and materials than the firmness rating of the mattress.

Some product specifications will have an ILD (Indentation Load Deflection) or IFD (Indentation Force Deflection) number, which is how much weight you would need to apply to depress a foam sample by a prescribed amount. In looking to compare across manufacturers, you will want to treat the ILD with caution since it will depend on how the value will be reported (newtons or pound-force), which percentage of the sample’s compression will be used (25%, 40%, or 65%), and the sample’s thickness. [SleepOnLatex points out] that the ILD number cannot be used to compare products from different companies. The [long Mattress Underground explainer] further explains this as a practitioner’s perspective, where the number at 25% does describe the layer under that amount of compression, but does not provide any indication as to how the foam layer will react when compressed as far down into a mattress as possible, combined with the thickness of the layer.

What you should focus on in a product page is the thickness of the material in the comfort layer, whether or not there is a transition layer, what kind of material is used in the core construction, and if there is any kind of zoning claim on the page. You can verify zoning claims using the method described by Consumer Reports, who tests mattresses that claim to have zones based on the amount the roller sinks into the mattress at various points along the length of the mattress. Zoning claims can be verified by how much a roller sinks into the mattress along the length of the mattress. A lumbar zone is measurable while a firmness number alone is not.

Showroom vs. Night One: Why New Mattresses Feel Firmer

Published mattress ratings reflect the state of the mattress at a single point in time, which is usually when the product was new. Consumer Reports measures how firm a mattress is when purchased new and then re-measures it after the mattress has undergone a “roller” durability test; both of these tests will result in a separate score based on how much the mattress changed from the original score due to its history of use. Similarly, the European method also takes into account the “roller” test before and after rolling; thus, the lab considers the level of firmness being tested to be a variable that changes over time; however, the product page shows you only one number (i.e., the most recent result).

The showroom also adds a third variable: City Mattress, for example, will inform its customers that because the display model is “broken in by dozens of people,” it will feel firmer than the new mattress you are purchasing. City Mattress tells buyers that a new mattress may feel firmer than the display model. They recommend that customers give their new mattress at least 30 days of sleeping on it before making a decision regarding the comfort level. Commenters on r/Mattress have also said that they heard this from a salesperson; one reported that they had to wait two to three months for their medium mattress to feel softer; another said that Brooklyn Bedding sent them a free firm topper to alleviate the discomfort they experienced on the medium mattress. Neither of these two comments reported a specific number regarding how much softening occurred, so be cautious of pages that promise a specific percentage of softening.

The rules regarding return policies are historically consistent with the stated time lag. Under Nectar’s trial policy (which takes effect on July 28, 2026), customers must wait 30 days after the date of delivery before they can initiate a return on a mattress that has been opened. This means that if a customer hasn’t opened their mattress within 90 days, it will be considered “misuse.” Therefore, although the customer has a 30-day minimum trial period in which to judge their mattress, their first week does not count.

The first thing you should do is ask yourself three questions before you rely on any published rating – Who’s body was it tested on? What was the base that was tested on? And what was the sample size? For example, Consumer Report, when testing queen mattresses, test them on a flat surface with mannequin weights of 121 lbs and 220 lbs (approx. 55 kg and 100 kg). If your body type or the type of bed you sleep on is significantly different than those used in the testing (e.g., the surface), then the rating will be for a different situation than the one you are in.

The Weight Test: Checking Softness Without a Lab

While it is impossible to perform a standards test on your own, it is possible to do an informal comparison between different mattresses by placing them under a weighted load that is the same. Many people who are testing mattresses will conduct a similar type of informal comparison. For example, The Guardian tester used a 7.5 kg weight on the middle of the mattress and used a string line and ruler to measure how much “give” each mattress had. The softest mattress had approximately 4 centimetres of “give” while the firmest mattress had approximately 1.8 centimetres of “give”. NapLab sets a 12 lb ball and tests mattresses by placing it approximately 12 inches from the edge of the mattress.

  1. Pick one known weight. Use dumbbells or a bag of known mass, and write the mass in both kg and lb.
  1. Keep the footprint and base the same. Use the same weight on every mattress, laid on a solid surface or the same base each time.
  1. Stretch a straight reference line. Pull a string tight across the surface, or rest a straightedge on two books.
  1. Place the weight in the same spot. Centre it, about a foot in from the edge.
  1. Wait the same time, then measure. Measure from the reference line down to the lowest point beside the weight.
  • Repeat on day 1, around day 30, and near the end of your trial. This tracks how your own bed changes.

What you get from doing this type of informal testing on your own is not going to be an ASTM or EN 1957 rating but rather an indication of how soft versus firm the mattress is under the same loading condition. The small weight will provide you with some information about how soft/firm the mattress is at the surface when compared to other mattresses, but not necessarily about how your hips will “sink into” the mattress. As a result, NapLab treats sinkage as a matter of personal preference rather than providing a score rating. This is one of the reasons why this type of testing can be useful for you, as it will help you compare the mattresses that you are considering based on how soft they feel under the same consistent conditions.

Set Your Starting Band: Weight, Position, and the Trial Plan

Each starting range is supplied by a source on that source’s own scale. Before buying, make sure to convert this range with your brand’s chart.

Step What to fill in Where the starting point comes from
1. Weight band Under 130 lb / 130–230 lb / over 230 lb Sleep Foundation bands: soft to medium (3–5) under 130 lb; medium to medium-firm in the middle; medium-firm (6) to firm (7–8) over 230 lb
2. Main position Side / back / stomach / combination Sleep Doctor ranges: side 4–6, back 5–7, stomach 5–9
3. Your band Where steps 1 and 2 overlap Your own synthesis; lean softer for side sleeping, firmer for stomach sleeping
4. Brand translation The brand’s word for your band, e.g. “medium-firm” The brand’s own chart; match the words, not the digit
5. Layer check Comfort-layer material and thickness, core, zoning claims The product page
6. Trial terms Trial length, earliest return date, return fees, exchange or topper options The brand’s policy page, with its effective date
7. Feel log Notes and weight-test depth on day 1, ~30, end of trial Your own measurements

Here’s how to use the result. If you land between two bands, firming up a soft bed is often harder than softening a firm one. Sleep Foundation suggests a plush topper when a mattress is too firm and a firm topper or sturdier foundation when it’s too soft. One Reddit buyer’s advice was to “go a little firmer” than you think, since their bed softened. That’s one person’s experience, not a rule. If you share a bed and your bands don’t overlap, Purple and Sleep Doctor both point to split king or dual-firmness designs.

Read the fine print of any trial offer before relying on it. Nectar’s policy requires that a proper base, frame, or foundation be used and that any mattress returned must be in a condition that allows it to be donated. It also states that the trial is only effective if its rules are followed.

What to Look For First

Identify your weight and preferred sleeping position (e.g., back, side, stomach). Find the exact language each brand uses for those weight categories on their charts since the numbers vary by retailer. Create a list of mattresses you think might work, but check each one’s comfort layer construction and warranty details before comparing them based on firmness ratings. Evaluate the mattress’ performance only after the minimum trial time period has passed and ideally with the same weight tests you performed initially.

Frequently Asked Questions

Does a different bed base change how firm a mattress feels?

Because changing the base alters how the mattress’s feel is experienced, Consumer Reports uses a solid foundation for its tests rather than a box spring. As per Sleep Foundation, having a more robust base can increase the firmness of the mattress. However, you should ensure that a new base is compatible with your current mattress.

Do adjustable air beds use the same firmness scale?

The firmness of adjustable airbeds does not adhere to the European method of measuring firmness for mattresses, which doesn’t apply to air beds. When measuring by the 1-10 scale, the firmness of an airbed may or may not be comparable to that of other brands. This is because the firmness measurement of an airbed includes the settings on the same bed.

What if my weight changes after I buy?

Additionally, weight gain or loss may affect how firm or soft the mattress feels after you purchase it due to how far or how much a load sinks into the mattress. If you’ve lost weight and feel that your mattress is now too firm, Sleep Foundation recommends using a softer or thicker mattress topper or the opposite if you have gained weight and the mattress is too soft.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Back to top button